What is threat simulation theory?
Threat simulation theory proposes that dreams evolved to rehearse dangerous situations. On this view, the sleeping brain runs simulated threats, such as being chased or attacked, so that a person can practice responses that would help them survive. The theory is one of several explanations for why dreams happen and why they often contain danger. It is supported by some evidence, but it has also drawn serious criticism, and it has not been firmly established.
What the theory claims
Antti Revonsuo proposed the theory in a 2000 paper in Behavioral and Brain Sciences. The central claim is that dreaming has an evolutionary function. Threatening events are common in dreams, and threat-avoidance skills may be practiced during them. If that is right, dreams would help the brain rehearse responses to danger in a safe setting.
The theory makes a specific prediction: threatening content should be more common in dreams than would be expected from waking life alone, and it should be linked to threats that a person actually faces or has faced.
The evidence that is cited
Supporters point to several findings:
- Threats are common in dreams. Content analyses of dream reports have found that aggression, misfortune, and danger appear frequently. This is consistent with the idea that dreams focus on threat, though the amount of threat depends on how dreams are coded and who reports them.
- Negative emotion is common. Research on dream emotions has found that many dreams involve strong feelings, and that negative feelings are often prominent. This fits a model in which dreams work on threat-related emotion.
- Trauma and dream threat. A 2005 study by Katja Valli, Revonsuo, and colleagues compared dreams of children who had lived through trauma with those of children who had not. The traumatized group reported more threatening dreams. This is one of the main pieces of evidence for the theory, although it is correlational and involves a specific population.
How rehearsal might help
If dreams rehearse threats, the practice might help in several ways. A person could test responses in a simulated setting, such as running, hiding, or fighting. Repeated practice might also help the brain learn to respond to danger faster or with less panic. The emotional side of threat dreams could also help a person process fear. These are plausible ideas, but none has been directly shown in people.
Criticisms and alternatives
Several objections are important.
Not all dreams are threatening. Many dreams are neutral, pleasant, or ordinary. A theory about threat has to explain why these dreams occur too. Threat simulation theory says that threatening dreams are the main function, but critics argue that the theory does not account for the whole range of dream content.
Dreams may reflect waking life. The continuity hypothesis, developed by G. William Domhoff and others, holds that dream content mirrors waking concerns, including stress and conflict. Threat themes could reflect what is stressful in a person’s life, without any function of rehearsal. Continuity can explain many of the same patterns that threat simulation explains.
Threat may be a by-product. Philosopher Owen Flanagan described some features of dreaming as “spandrels,” meaning side effects of sleep rather than adaptations. On this view, threat in dreams might be a byproduct of emotional processing rather than a trained function.
Testing the function is hard. Claims about evolutionary function are difficult to test directly. A theory can fit many findings, and it can be hard to show that a specific dream helped a specific person survive.
What a fair test would look like
A stronger test would check predictions that the theory makes and that rival theories do not. For example, researchers could examine whether threatening dreams increase after a real threat, whether they lead to practice of specific responses, or whether the content changes in ways that suggest rehearsal. Some work of this kind has been done, but the results are not yet decisive.
How it fits with other models
Threat simulation theory is one of several explanations of dreaming. Activation-synthesis theory focuses on how the brain builds dream stories from brain signals, not on what dreams are for. The problem-solving theory proposes that dreams help people work on waking concerns. The continuity hypothesis, which is part of the same debate, treats threat themes as one kind of waking concern.
For a closer look at the most common dream themes, including being chased, see the most common dream themes and what studies found. For the brain research that informs these models, see the neuroscience of dreaming. For the broader field, see oneirology, the scientific study of dreams.
For a related idea about what animals may replay during sleep, see do animals dream?.
Bottom line
Threat simulation theory proposes that dreams rehearse danger so that we can practice responses. The theory has some support, especially from the frequency of threat in dreams and from studies of trauma. But it is contested, it does not explain all dream content, and it is hard to test. Treat it as a serious hypothesis rather than an established fact.