Dream Science

Do Animals Dream? What Brain Studies Suggest

Animals show REM sleep and brain activity that replays waking life, but their inner experience cannot be confirmed. Here is what studies suggest.

On this page
  1. Do animals dream?
  2. Why we cannot ask animals
  3. REM sleep across animals
  4. Cats and REM without atonia
  5. Rats replaying maze runs
  6. Zebra finches replaying song
  7. REM sleep behavior disorder as a human window
  8. Replay is not the same as experience
  9. Bottom line

Do animals dream?

Animals show sleep patterns and brain activity that look similar to human REM sleep, the stage where most vivid dreams occur. In some studies, the brain activity of sleeping animals replays what they did while awake. These findings suggest that some animals may have dream-like experiences. But no one can confirm what an animal experiences while asleep, so the honest answer is that animals may dream, and the evidence cannot settle what that dreaming is like.

Why we cannot ask animals

Dream research depends on people describing their dreams after waking. Animals cannot do this. Researchers have instead used two kinds of evidence: how an animal’s body behaves during sleep, and what its brain activity looks like. Both approaches give useful clues, but neither gives direct access to experience.

Aristotle wrote about animal sleep and suggested that dogs and horses appeared to dream. Modern studies are far more detailed, but the core problem remains the same.

REM sleep across animals

REM sleep, or a close equivalent, has been well documented in mammals and birds. During REM, the brain shows fast, low-voltage activity similar to waking, and muscles are largely switched off. Evidence for REM-like sleep in other animals, such as reptiles, is less clear and is still being studied. The amount of REM sleep also varies a great deal between species.

Cats and REM without atonia

In 1965, the French researchers Michel Jouvet and J. F. Delorme found that damage to a part of the brainstem called the pons prevented cats from losing muscle tone during REM sleep. They called this state “REM without atonia.” Instead of staying still, the cats moved around and behaved in ways that looked like hunting or aggression.

Later reviews have described cats in this state turning their heads as though following something, and some showing movements that look like pouncing on prey. These movements suggest that the sleeping cat may be acting out something related to its waking behavior. This is a reasonable inference, but it is still an inference about what the cat’s brain is doing, not about what the cat experiences.

Rats replaying maze runs

Work by Matthew Wilson and colleagues at MIT examined brain cells in the hippocampus, a region involved in forming memories. Researchers first recorded which cells fired while a rat ran a maze. Later, during REM sleep, the same cells fired in the same order. The pattern was clear enough that researchers could estimate where the sleeping rat was in its “mental” maze.

This is one of the strongest findings in the field. It shows that the sleeping brain can replay past experience in a structured way. What it does not show is whether the rat is aware of this replay as a dream.

Zebra finches replaying song

Amish Dave and Daniel Margoliash studied zebra finches, which learn their songs as young birds. While the birds sang, researchers recorded firing patterns in a forebrain area involved in singing. Those patterns could be used to reconstruct the song. Later, during sleep, the same areas fired in sequences that matched the song.

Like the rat studies, this shows replay of learned activity during sleep. The birds may be rehearsing their songs, but whether that counts as dreaming depends on how dreaming is defined.

REM sleep behavior disorder as a human window

People with REM sleep behavior disorder lose the normal muscle paralysis of REM sleep, so they can act out dreams. They may punch, kick, or run while asleep, and their actions often match what they report dreaming about. This condition shows that the link between dream content and movement exists in humans too. It is a medical condition and should be assessed by a doctor if it occurs.

Replay is not the same as experience

The studies above show several things:

  • Many animals have REM-like sleep, with brain activity similar to waking in some respects.
  • Brain activity during sleep can replay waking experience in a structured way.
  • Some animals move during sleep in ways that seem related to waking behavior.

These findings do not show what an animal experiences. Replay in the brain could happen without any dreamlike experience. Movement during sleep could be a motor pattern without a dream behind it. Scientists disagree about where to draw the line between dreaming and simply having active brain patterns during sleep.

For this reason, the best current answer is cautious. Animals may have dream-like experiences, and the brain patterns suggest that some of them replay their waking lives. What it is like to be an animal in that state remains unknown. For background on how dreams are studied in people, see oneirology, the scientific study of dreams. For the sleep stage itself, see REM sleep and dreaming, and for the broader brain research, see the neuroscience of dreaming.

For a related question about what dream content looks like in people, see the most common dream themes and what studies found. For the theory that dreams may rehearse threats, which some have connected to animal behavior, see threat simulation theory.

Bottom line

Animals show REM-like sleep and brain activity that can replay waking experience, and some move in ways that look like their waking behavior. These findings make it reasonable to think animals may dream. Whether that dreaming involves any experience, and what it would be like, cannot yet be known.

The complete guide to dream science

Oneirology: The Scientific Study of Dreams
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →