Basics

Can Lucid Dreaming Help With Nightmares? What Research Shows

Can lucid dreaming help with nightmares? Small studies suggest it may help some people. Learn what the research shows, its limits, and when to see a clinician.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. How lucidity can change a nightmare
  3. What the studies show
  4. How this compares with imagery rehearsal therapy
  5. When nightmares are part of PTSD or another condition
  6. Risks to know
  7. If you want to try it
  8. Where to go next

Short answer

Some small studies suggest lucid dreaming can help some people have fewer nightmares, or make them less frightening. The evidence is limited, and lucid dreaming is not a replacement for medical care. If nightmares are frequent, distressing, or linked to trauma, talk to a clinician.

How lucidity can change a nightmare

Realizing you are dreaming can take some of the fear away, because you know the danger is not physically real. Once you are lucid, you may be able to change the scene, face the figure chasing you, or change how the dream ends.

Some clinicians suggest staying in the dream rather than forcing yourself awake, so you can work with it. This approach is debated, and it should be tried carefully.

What the studies show

  • A 2006 pilot study by Spoormaker and van den Bout, summarized on Wikipedia, found that lucid dreaming treatment reduced how often people had nightmares. The authors were not sure whether the lucidity itself or the changing of the dream was responsible.
  • A study by Holzinger and colleagues, also cited on Wikipedia, included 40 people with nightmares. Among the 24 who were taught lucid dreaming, the authors reported fewer nightmares. The study was small, so the result is a starting point, not proof.

Most of these studies are small pilot studies or case series. Many did not compare results against a control group. That is why the results are promising but not conclusive.

How this compares with imagery rehearsal therapy

Imagery rehearsal therapy is a well-studied approach for chronic nightmares. You write down a recurring nightmare, change it into a new story you would prefer, and rehearse that version while awake. It is among the better-established options for nightmare disorder.

Lucid dreaming therapy shares some of the same ideas, but its evidence base is thinner. BrainFacts/SfN reports that the American Academy of Sleep Medicine began recommending lucid dreaming as a treatment for nightmare disorder in 2018. Check that guidance directly if you need its exact wording.

When nightmares are part of PTSD or another condition

Nightmares are a common part of post-traumatic stress disorder. Treatment for PTSD usually involves a clinician trained in trauma care. Lucid dreaming should not be a substitute for that care. If you have PTSD, talk to your clinician before trying lucid dreaming techniques.

Risks to know

  • Sleep disruption. Many techniques involve waking during the night, which can cut into sleep you need.
  • Sleep paralysis. Attempts at lucidity can bring on sleep paralysis, which can be frightening.
  • Feeling trapped. Some people realize they are dreaming but still feel trapped by a frightening scene. Knowing a dream is not real does not always stop the fear.
  • Emotional strain. Facing a frightening dream on purpose can be upsetting, especially for people with trauma.

If you want to try it

Talk to a doctor or sleep specialist first, especially if nightmares are frequent or tied to trauma. If you try self-guided practice, keep it gentle. Do not force yourself to stay in a frightening dream, and stop if the practice makes you more anxious or disturbs your sleep. Do not use supplements or aids for this without medical advice.

Where to go next

For the basics of what lucid dreaming is, see the pillar article on lucid dreaming. To see the wider picture of whether lucid dreaming is good for wellbeing, read whether lucid dreaming is good for mental health. If you want to know how much control a dreamer really has, see whether you can really control your dreams.

The complete guide to basics

What Is Lucid Dreaming? Meaning and Definition
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →